With steroid
controversies popping up in nearly every sport, it would be easy to associate
"supplement" with "steroid." However, not everything used to help weightlifters
and athletes with their workout routines is illegal.
There are hundreds
of different types of supplements people use in order to help bulk up in
the weight room, said Jane Foos, clinical sports dietitian of Red Cedar
Medical Center.
"I work from
a nutritional basis, assess the total nutritional intake and devise a plan
to get extra calories and proteins (athletes) need," Foos said. "I recommend
food first then supplements as needed."
She said some
of the more popular supplements used today include whey protein, creatine,
amino acids and fat blockers. She added there is a strong difference between
whey and creatine.
"Whey protein
has all of the amino acids required to build and repair muscle tissues
but creatine is a totally different product," she said. "It is an ingredient
that helps athletes to do multiple explosive efforts and has to be regenerated
during the rest phase so they can lift the next set.
"Creatine is
not involved in muscle building or repair and many whey protein supplements
contain creatine."
Junior Billy
Raleigh said he lifts three to four days a week, depending on his schedule,
but only uses whey protein supplement and dextrose, a type of sugar.
"After lifting,
(whey protein and dextrose) help to repair muscles after you've stretched
them out and pushed them past the point they're adapted to," he said. "It
gives a faster recovery and helps retain strength better."
He said he started
using products his freshman year at UW-Eau Claire but has never taken anything
that is considered controversial.
"I got into
using them around the beginning of college," Raleigh said. "I'm not into
it as much as some people are … it's like a lifestyle for them."
Although he
said he hasn't had a lot of time this semester to get into a weight lifting
routine, sophomore Ryan Fish said he has used a variety of supplements
to help with his workout he used to do five days a week.
"When I was
over in Iraq, I used BSN products that push more blood to your muscles
while you lift," Fish said. "BSN products have been solid to me … my roommates
take them, too."
Foos said many
of the calories and proteins people look for in supplements come naturally
in foods.
"Whey comes
from milk … most people don't know that," she said. "Creatine is a naturally
occurring substance in the body that allows you to lift more sets for more
energy … if you can do the final set with the same power and energy as
the first set, you're going to have strength improvement over time."
Last year, Raleigh
said he tried using creatine, but gave it up because he said it gave him
a "false impression of how good (he was) doing."
"I put on a
good 10 pounds, (but) then fell back and lost half of that keeping up my
normal routine without creatine," he said. "It looks good at the start
but I couldn't retain it without continued use."
Despite its
popularity, Foos said creatine only works for 50 percent of users.
"People know
if they respond to it or not … if someone is a non-responder, it means
the body (muscles) have enough creatine in it already," she said. "Responders
don't have enough creatine."
She said the
weight gain, like the one Raleigh experienced, comes from the body holding
water in. The initial weight change is in water weight from a responder.
Foos also said
concerns about supplements include the possibility of taking too much of
a substance resulting in a high weight gain.
However, she
said there hasn't been any research that has identified any negative effects
from creatine, assuming the person using it is a healthy adult.
"If you take
more of a product than the body needs, you'll get fat," she said. "Too
much protein and too much calories lead to more body fat."
Foos said there
are two things to look for in a product - purity and potency. Purity involves
whether the product contains the ingredients listed on the label and if
is actually free of anything not on the label, she said. Potency entails
whether a product has the listed amount of a substance.
Problems can
also stem from companies not being regulated by the Food and Drug Administration,
Foos added.
"Because supplements
are not governed by the FDA, there's no law that says they have to have
pure potency and that's the problem," she said. "I don't recommend (supplements)
by name because I don't know what's in that can either. That's the real
danger."
Overall, Raleigh
said he's been satisfied with how the supplements have helped him progress
when working out.
"I like it.
There's a fine line between utilizing a supplement and overdoing it," he
said. "It gives a little push during workouts, but doesn't overdo anything."
--
Copyright
2007 by United Press International.
All rights reserved.
--
|